This debate packet explores the complex balance between scientific discovery, technological progress, and societal needs. Participants will examine questions such as whether radio astronomy should receive priority access to certain spectrum bands, whether governments should establish or expand quiet zones, and whether international treaties should play a stronger role in global spectrum management. As you review the materials, consider both the immediate benefits of connectivity and commercial technologies, and the long-term value of preserving the ability to explore the cosmos. The goal of these debates is to weigh competing priorities and explore how society can manage a shared and increasingly crowded resource.